And the
fragrance
filled the house...
John 12:1-8
Text
here is from the New King James Version ©1984,
Thomas Nelson, Inc.
(normally I use the NRSV, but thought I'd vary a bit)
Prelude
In John's gospel, this
episode is intimately tied with what precedes it. Chapter 11 tells the
story of the raising of Lazarus and, in fact, begins with an allusion to
chapter 12: "Now a certain man was sick, Lazarus of Bethany, the
town of Mary and her sister Martha. It was that Mary who anointed the Lord
with fragrant oil and wiped His feet with her hair, whose brother Lazarus
was sick." (John 11:1-2) Call it a
preview of coming attractions.
Briefly told, the sisters send
word to Jesus of their brother's illness (11:3), but
Jesus chooses to take his own time traveling there (11:5-16).
More is going on in this scene than the illness of a dear friend. In
John's gospel, Jesus is always far ahead of those who follow. His words
are very often misunderstood, which is very evident in this chapter, where
he heads to Bethany with a larger purpose than healing a loved one. As he
nears, Martha meets him outside of town (11:17-27),
and shares the news of Lazarus' death. Does she understand when he says,
"I am the resurrection and the life..."? She responds
with a creed of lofty titles (Messiah, Son of God, Coming One), but
has the impact of him being the "resurrection" and "life"
itself flown over her head also?
Mary then comes to Jesus
at Martha's prodding, falling at his feet when she does. "If you had
been here, Lord, my brother would not have died," she says through
her tears. She, a friend, also cannot see the bigger picture. The two of
them are surrounded by (professional?) mourners, and when he asks about
Lazarus' body, these others speak Jesus' own line - "Come and see!"
However, theirs is an invitation to observe death, not life. This is
too much, and Jesus weeps in frustration (11:28-37).
From there he goes to the tomb and, by his very word, raises Lazarus
from the dead (11:38-44) - a foretaste of what lies
around the next bend in Jerusalem. The die is cast, his opponents now decide the time
has come for this "one man to die that the whole nation
not be destroyed" (11:45-57). Passover
is near. Thus we arrive at this
text. |
|
{1} Then, six days before the Passover, Jesus came to
Bethany,
where Lazarus was who had
been
dead,
whom He had raised from the dead.
{2}
There they made Him a supper; and Martha served, but
Lazarus was one of those who sat at the table with Him.
{3} Then Mary took a pound of
very costly oil of spikenard,
anointed the feet of Jesus, and
wiped His feet with her hair.
And the house was filled with the fragrance of the oil.
{4} Then one of His disciples,
Judas Iscariot,
Simon's son, who would betray Him, said,
{5}
"Why was this fragrant oil not sold for three hundred denarii
and given to the poor?"
{6}
This he said, not that he cared for the poor, but
because he was a thief,
and had the money box;
and he used to take what was put in it.
{7} But Jesus said,
"Let her alone; she has kept this for the day of My burial.
{8}
For the poor you
have with you always,
but Me you do not
have
always."
|
Reflection
Can you
imagine such a meal? A dinner after a funeral provides an
opportunity for remembering the deceased and reconnecting ties
that have been strained or broken, but what happens when the
deceased is no longer dead? What do you talk about? No matter how
much time has elapsed between Lazarus' resurrection and this meal
(11:54
says that Jesus went to Ephraim and "remained there,"
but does not indicate how long), the aroma of that event
still lingers. Is it a pleasing odor? Recall the
"stench" of a body four days in the tomb (11:39),
but is that the abiding smell surrounding this meal? Gospel
storyteller John purposefully weaves his account in such a way
that whatever this "Word made flesh" (1:14),
Jesus, says and does shakes the foundations undergirding everyone
who encounters him. In fact, his death upon the cross will throw
the world into a decisive crisis (see 12:31-32
and 9:39,
where "judgment" in Greek is "krisis").
If the aroma of what previously happened in Bethany is too
pleasing, then perhaps we have not really smelled it.
Why did Mary
anoint Jesus' feet during this meal? Was it just simple devotion,
out of friendship for her beloved rabbi? Was she putting into
action something no words could express at such a meal? I
personally remember sitting at my own father's feet in his
hospital room before he died, seeking to convey something I did
not know how to speak. Was Mary aware of Jesus' impending death?
Did she, as Jesus said (12:7), consciously
buy the perfume for his funeral, or was her purchase only later
revealed (even to her) to have been for this purpose? How often do
our actions take on new meaning after we have done them?
Regardless of her motivations (which we do not know), the
fragrance of the costly oil filled the room as she anointed Jesus'
feet (soon, in Jerusalem, Jesus would wash the feet
of his disciples, 13:1-20).
The smell was too
much for Judas Iscariot. Was it merely Mary's perfumed oil against
which he reacted, or was the stench of the tomb earlier still
bothering him? Or, as the text says, was it all just a matter of
greed on his part? Whether it be for the poor or for his own
pocket, money was not the real issue. Of course, 300 denarii have
their own aroma, for good or for ill. However, the real fragrance
beginning to waft through the room is from the impending
crucifixion of Jesus, of which his disciples have caught only a
faint sniff. All too soon everything will change. No longer will
they sense his physical presence, but as he is lifted up, a time
of "krisis" for all, the scent of salvation will pervade
the world (3:17).
From here begins
John's telling of the events in Jerusalem. A crowd gathers when
they hear of Jesus and Lazarus together (12:9),
in response to which the religious elite include Lazarus as a
target in their plot to dispense with the Jesus problem (12:10-11).
The next day Jesus enters the City of David (12:12-19).
[In the Lenten lectionary sequence of year C, in
fact, "Palm Sunday" comes the week after this text is a
suggested reading]. |
|
Parallels
While all four gospels tell a version of this story, there are
significant differences. Matthew and Mark seem cut out of nearly the
same fabric, with an anonymous "woman" anointing Jesus'
head with oil as he sits at table in the house of Simon the leper.
John's account takes place in Bethany, like Matthew and Luke, but in
the home of Lazarus, Martha, and "Mary" - who is
this "woman." These three gospels agree (with
variation) on the reaction of the onlookers. Their revulsion to this
act revolves around the cost of the oil and the wastefulness of such
extravagance. Only in John is Judas Iscariot identified as the one
questioning the expenditure, and his motives in turn are questioned.
In all three, Jesus links the oil with his upcoming death - a
preparation, noting that the poor (as potential recipients of money
saved by not anointing) are a continuing part of the physical
landscape, while he (himself) will not be. Matthew and Mark agree
fully on the final statement about how this woman will be remembered
by future generations.
In all four stories, there is a "Simon." In Matthew and
Mark, this episode takes place at the house of "Simon the
leper" (some have speculated - juxtaposing Matthew, Mark, and
John - that he might have been the husband of Martha, or father of
her and her two siblings, but there is scant evidence for this). In
John, "Simon" is mentioned as the father of Judas
Iscariot. The events in Luke take place in the home of a Pharisee
named "Simon." It is doubtful these three Simons are the
same person, but the common name serves as a bridge between these
texts.
Luke's story is an altogether different version, though it shares
some common elements. Is it the same story? The woman is still
anonymous, though she is identified as "a sinner" "in
the city," someone not to be "touched." In fact, that
is the issue in Luke - she is "unclean" (a sinner), and
thus ritually pollutes Jesus by physical contact with him. Jesus'
response (through parable and direct statement) to those who
question this woman's act, involves God's forgiveness. Hospitality rather than anointing for
impending death is what drives Luke's telling. In both John and
Luke, it is the feet of Jesus which are anointed, not his head (as
in Matthew and Mark). Overall, it is the fragrance of not only the oil,
but the deed as well, which is the aroma common to all four
gospels.
Parallels (in NRSV) are highlighted
in this way:
in all four (yellow),
in three of four
(green), in two of four
(blue) |
Matthew 26:6-13 |
Mark 14:3-9 |
Luke 7:36-50 |
John 12:1-8 |
{6} And when Jesus was in Bethany
at the house of Simon
the leper, |
{3} And being in Bethany
at the house of Simon
the leper, as He sat at the table, |
{36} Then one of the Pharisees asked Him to eat with
him. And He went to the Pharisee's house, and sat down to eat. |
{1} Then, six days before the Passover, Jesus came to Bethany,
where Lazarus was who had been dead, whom He had raised from the
dead. {2} There they made Him a supper; and Martha served, but
Lazarus was one of those who sat at the table with Him. |
{7} a woman
came to Him having an
alabaster flask of very
costly fragrant
oil, and she poured
it on His head as He sat at the table. |
a woman
came having an alabaster
flask of very costly
oil of spikenard.
Then she broke the flask and poured
it on His head. |
{37} And behold, a
woman in the city who was a sinner, when she knew that Jesus
sat at the table in the Pharisee's house, brought an
alabaster flask of fragrant
oil, {38} and stood
at His feet behind Him weeping; and she began to wash His
feet with her tears, and wiped them with the hair of her
head; and she kissed His
feet and anointed
them with the fragrant
oil. |
{3} Then Mary took a pound of very
costly oil
of spikenard, anointed
the feet of Jesus,
and wiped His feet
with her hair. And the house was filled with the fragrance
of the oil. |
{8} But when His disciples saw it, they were
indignant, saying, "Why
this waste? {9}
"For this fragrant
oil might
have been sold for
much and given to the poor." |
{4} But there were some who were
indignant among themselves, and said, "Why
was this
fragrant oil
wasted? {5} "For
it might have been sold
for more than three
hundred denarii and
given to the poor." And they criticized her sharply. |
{39} Now when the Pharisee who had invited Him saw
this, he spoke to himself, saying, "This man, if He were a
prophet, would know who and what manner of woman this is who is
touching Him, for she is a sinner." |
{4} Then one of His disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon's
son, who would betray Him, said, {5} "Why
was this
fragrant oil
not sold for three
hundred denarii and
given to the poor?" {6} This he said, not that he cared
for the poor, but because he was a thief, and had the money box; and
he used to take what was put in it. |
{10} But when Jesus was aware of it, He said to them,
"Why do you trouble
the woman? For she has done a good work for Me. {11} "For
you have the poor with you always, but
Me you do not have always. {12} "For in pouring this
fragrant oil on My body,
she did it for My burial.
|
{6} But Jesus said, "Let
her alone. Why do you
trouble her? She has done a good work for Me. {7} "For
you have the poor with you always, and whenever you wish you
may do them good; but Me you
do not have always. {8} "She has done what she could.
She has come beforehand to anoint My
body for
burial. |
|
{7} But Jesus said, "Let
her alone; she has kept this for
the day of My burial.
{8} "For the poor you
have with you always, but
Me you do not have always." |
{13} "Assuredly,
I say to you, wherever this gospel is preached in the whole world,
what this woman has done will also be told as a memorial to her." |
{9} "Assuredly,
I say to you, wherever this gospel is preached in the whole world,
what this woman has done will also be told as a memorial to her." |
|
|
|
|
{40} And Jesus answered and said to him, "Simon,
I have something to say to you." So he said, "Teacher, say
it." {41} "There was a certain creditor who had two
debtors. One owed five hundred denarii, and the other fifty. {42}
"And when they had nothing with which to repay, he freely
forgave them both. Tell Me, therefore, which of them will love him
more?" {43} Simon answered and said, "I suppose the one
whom he forgave more." And He said to him, "You have
rightly judged." {44} Then He turned to the woman and said to
Simon, "Do you see this woman? I entered your house; you gave
Me no water for My feet,
but she has washed My feet
with her tears and wiped them with the hair of her head. {45}
"You gave Me no kiss, but this woman has not ceased to kiss My feet
since the time I came in. {46} "You did not anoint My head with
oil, but this woman has anointed My feet
with fragrant oil.
{47} "Therefore I say to you, her sins, which are many, are
forgiven, for she loved much. But to whom little is forgiven, the
same loves little." {48} Then He said to her, "Your sins
are forgiven." {49} And those who sat at the table with Him
began to say to themselves, "Who is this who even forgives
sins?" {50} Then He said to the woman, "Your faith has
saved you. Go in peace." |
|
|